Jason Moyer on 18/12/2009 at 00:31
(insert some mindless, condescending rebuttal here)
Zygoptera on 18/12/2009 at 00:41
Nonono it's:
[4chan meme]
[irrelevant image macro involving cats/ badly drawn cartoon]
[swarm of incongruous smilies]
Gryzemuis on 18/12/2009 at 04:57
I understand that tastes are different.
Especially when considering so many different genres.
But even when taking that into account, there are a few weid inconsistencies. All imho of course.
They have UT2004 and Quake3 Arena on the list. But not Unreal Tournament 99. Weird. UT99 was a more complete game, with more players online, longer longevity, and it made much impact at the time than UT2004 ever made.
They have Oblivion high in the list. But they forgot about Morrowind ?? While I think Morrowind again was more revolutionary at the time. And had better game play. And less criticism.
They have Crysis and Far Cry 2 on the list. But not the original Far Cry. Imho, the original Far Cry was excellent. And the huge, open, green, all-lit world was something new at the time.
Half-Life 1 deserves its high spot. But where is Unreal ? Not as good, but in some ways just as "next-generation" as HL1 was. Unreal doesn't deserve a top-spot, but certainly in the top-100.
I'd love to have seen Undying on the list. But I guess you can't have it all. Thief 2 and System Shock 2 on that list is already pretty amazing.
Andarthiel on 18/12/2009 at 06:28
Not a good list, very inconsistent as Flower said and the top ten don't make much sense as well. KOTOR should be in the top 10 not in 94 or whatever it was. Deus Ex doesn't deserve no.1 but then again that's just my taste talking. I lol'd @ WoW in no.14.
Koki on 18/12/2009 at 06:32
I could probably accept this if they dropped the num-Fallout 3? Scratch all that and nuke it from orbit.
denisv on 18/12/2009 at 07:05
Quote Posted by reizak
How about GTA IV as the 15th best PC game of all time? I suppose it's possible to play it on the PC, so technically it qualifies, but have these people no self-respect? A distinction should be made between a PC game and sloppy scraps dumped on the platform.
GTA 4 played fine on PCs. Get a better 'puter and stop whining. Whiner.
SubJeff on 18/12/2009 at 07:13
Quote Posted by Jason Moyer
(insert some mindless, condescending rebuttal here)
Why should I bother if you can't. Everything else I would say would be a reiteration of previous posts because you've read what I posted, but you obviously haven't actually paid attention and its not my job to explain the world to you.
And I was going to bed so couldn't be arsed to type this.
Edit: actually denisv everyone and your mother knows there are still massive problems with GTAIVs performance on PC so probably best you shut up before someone rolls out the penisv tag.
june gloom on 18/12/2009 at 07:19
Quote Posted by denisv
GTA 4 played fine on PCs. Get a better 'puter and stop whining. Whiner.
hahahahahahaha are you fucking kidding me? Or did the forum software fuck up and this is really Jashin?
Yakoob on 18/12/2009 at 08:56
Quote Posted by Andarthiel
I lol'd @ WoW in no.14.
You may not like it, but the fact of the matter is that WoW has captured millions and has been, de-facto, the biggest and most successful game of all time. Disagree with this all you want but, for that fact alone, it does more than deserve to be in the top 100, if not top 10, games of all time.
Koki on 18/12/2009 at 09:01
No, Sims Solitaire.
