jtr7 on 16/1/2009 at 11:01
Only just found this, even though I've done searches for "Dark Camelot" and "Better Red Than Undead" several times before.:tsktsk:
There's part of another Interview with Doug Church, as well as a link to the Kieron Gillen interview above, plus a plug for the book the interview portion was excerpted from:
(
http://www.adventuregamers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=9683)
Eigenface on 4/3/2009 at 23:55
As I see it, the thief factions are the worst possible sides of various groups in the real world. For example, the Hammerites represent the Christian church at its most witch-burning, Crusading, and Spanish-Inquiring. This done so that Garrett the criminal seems like the good guy, rebelling against a world that's completely corrupt at every turn. Stealing? It's okay, because they're snobby nobles who make their wine from the blood and sweat of the common man. Killing? It's okay, because they're religious fanatics spreading blind obedience through brainwashing and torture. This creates a pretty pessimistic viewpoint, but on the other hand, Garrett wouldn't be a very sympathetic protagonist if he stole candy from babies and murdered their mothers.
The only part that really bothers me about the thief world is how they conflate different things, that is, they poison good things by mixing them together with bad things. For example, because the slave-making Mechanists are the ones pushing for technological progress, technological progress itself starts to look bad. Nature conservation takes the form of the pagans slaughtering the Hammerites en masse. Garrett is keeper of the balance. Things exist on one side or the other of a scale, and life is better when the scale is in balance, not when the good side is heavier - there is no real good side. This creates a really pessimistic viewpoint.
Beleg Cúthalion on 5/3/2009 at 07:35
Steampunk, according to my best friend Wikipedia,
is dystopic by definition. Just those pictures from classical Victorian Era Steampunk with air ships and bright skies might spoil this image.
Oh, and just to be hairsplitting: Witches were condemned by courts of law, at least in Germany (and I believe we got the most witches :p). There might have been a religious feeling of justice, but it was no issue of the church (left aside that the (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malleus_Maleficarum) Witch Hammer was written by a monk afraid of women). Funnily, in Spain, where believing in witches was, according to the
canon episcopi, forbidden, the desire for violence went into the inquisition.
In one more attempt to ask for more depth in FMs: Why do we hear so little about religiousness in the public, why is the "Builder belief" to restricted to the Hammerites and small chapels in mansions?
Jah on 5/3/2009 at 09:03
Quote Posted by Beleg Cúthalion
In one more attempt to ask for more depth in FMs: Why do we hear so little about religiousness in the public, why is the "Builder belief" to restricted to the Hammerites and small chapels in mansions?
Depends on what you mean by "public religiousness", I guess. I remember many FM's with readables where common folk invoke the name of the Builder in times of peril, so I never got the impression that religion was restricted to the Hammerites and the lip service given by the nobles to please the church. But it's true that in most FM's, the only people you ever see inside Hammerite churches and cathedrals are the Hammerites themselves; there don't seem to be many scenes of commoners attending a Hammerite service. (Then again, most FM's take place during the night, so maybe that's why.)
jtr7 on 5/3/2009 at 09:17
Quote:
mc10407C: "To find the answer to that question, thou must attend the Mechanist Seminary, and join our Order. The wisdom of Karras is not for the eyes of the 'common' man."
The nobility put on airs about many things, perhaps they keep their beliefs closeted, or maybe even just personal. It's hard to tell if all the available seats in the mansion chapels are actually ever filled, or if it's just for show to keep within the Hammers' good graces:
[INDENT]"
M09B05: [Truart,] I know well that thy father [Iblis Truart] was a loyal supporter in time gone by. Most greatly did we appreciate his generosity in building the chapel upon Truart Estate, where mine brethren and myself did give praise to the Builder. However, the worship of the Builder has come forward while thy chapel dost remain in the past, for its walls and panels art still decked in the symbols of our old ways. For one who hast renounced these antique trappings, such things are deeply offensive. Thou must think strongly upon replacing them with the more modern and appropriate symbols of the present age.
-Brother Tickspring"[/INDENT]
----------
[INDENT]
MISCB18: "Friends-
Know thou that our Lord Karras was most disappointed by the attendance at his sermon two nights past. Though thine own faces were well seen, it is not sufficient in the Builder's eyes for thee to come alone. Know that all of
thee must not only attend in thine own person, but must seek to bring as many of the city's elite as thou canst turn the ear of. Master Karras desires this patronage, and I know his disciples shalt not disappoint."[/INDENT]
----------
[INDENT]
mc10604D: (Wondering at) "Thou wert not with the Hammer before?"
mc20604E: "Nay. Those brothers wert always too stern and righteous, for my choice. And they turned their faces away from our Lord Karras when he spoke of progress. When I heard of the great works he had made since he left them, I came."[/INDENT]
----------
[INDENT]
hm1c1401: "Time was all these halls would be close-packed with novices, striving to learn our teachings."
hm3c1402: "There are novices still!"
hm1c1403: "But fewer brother, fewer. Youths in this time seek to learn about gold and politics, not honest craft."
hm3c1404: "'Twill be their loss when they come of age and know not how to accomplish aught of consequence."[/INDENT]
Hmmm. How DID Constantine get this GENUINE letter of introduction? By killing the original carrier, perhaps?
[INDENT]
M10HallPass: "As approved by his Eminence, the High Priest Markander, we deliver unto you this Novice, under the standard agreement of service. The Novice is sent with full status and training as such, and should serve with humility and vigor to the best of his skills. He will endure a standard three-year contract of service, at the end of which he will be considered for indoctrination as an Elevated Acolyte.
The novice has been instructed in the rules and strictures of the Order, has sworn his warrants to be silent in his vigils, and knows to maintain the marked privacies (as indicated by the standard inverted red hammer sigil).
Please remit periodic evaluations of his conduct, as warranted or at six-month intervals.
May the Hammer fall on the unrighteous.
Officially,
Brother Sachelman"[/INDENT]
----------
[INDENT]
M06B06: "Lord Karras:
Your sermon was so inspiring. I never thought of it that way, to be a little cog, floating around in a big boiler. SO warm and toasty, you see? Please accept my compliments, and do tell me you will come to the dinner we are having on Saturday.
Lady Einhorn"[/INDENT]
----------
Alyssa Hurley was called a "pious woman who dost attend services most regular."
There's the unused conversation between the Mechanist Priest and Masked Servant, about finally replacing Father Norell to "attend to Norell's former flock," because "There was naught he could do for these people, save lead them into the muck that mires his own mind."
There's also the "Benny" snorings where he mutters "Builder" in his sleep, and "Builder...bless me..."
[INDENT]
AULhammerleaflet: :D "Citizens- Art thou aware there are heathens in thy midst? Didst thou know the Master Builder judges all? Dost thou give thanks oft enough? If thou answered yea or nay to any of the above, then thou needs must attend our services. Thy very soul dost depend upon it! The Brothers of the Order of the Hammer"[/INDENT]
----------
[INDENT]
g5_obs_hammer1: "Just don't give me none of that 'Builder' stuff."[/INDENT]
[INDENT]
p4_obs_hammer1: (Singsong, under his breath, mockingly) "'Builder bes help me, builder bes help me'-- Oooh."[/INDENT]
[INDENT]
g1_obs_hammer1: "Builder bless you, or however you guys say."[/INDENT]
[INDENT]
s2_obs_hammer_friend1: "Builder watch over me too."[/INDENT]
[INDENT]
rmzbod_1: "Builder's Gold! An assassin! Guards, guards!"[/INDENT]
[INDENT]
Truart: "Yes...I'm glad your Builder guides you, but it would make me feel even more confident if you were to let me in on your...whole scheme."[/INDENT]
No such love for the Woodsie Lord.
Beleg Cúthalion on 5/3/2009 at 19:56
Not really love for the Builder either, which is kind of funny for this whole pseudo-medieval setting (however, but not for modern fantasy employing a lot of enlightened and modern thoughts that don't fit too well...on the other hand).
Thanks for the info, master librarian.
jtr7 on 3/5/2009 at 08:19
Quote Posted by Tim Stellmach
We toyed with a "Dark Camelot" idea where Arthur was the bad guy and you played
Modred. And
Modred was this kinda sneaky little guy. Interest in the Camelot theme didn't take off, but by the time we bagged it the
Modred concept had evolved into such a rogue that we went straight from there into the Thief game.
Sometimes I just spend too much time looking one way that I fail to see something in the other direction.
I know "Modred" is a fairly common spelling for "Mordred", but I can't believe it's never been pointed out that it's an anagram of "dromed". :p
And "modder". A Google search for DromEd with Modred found one guy with it on his list. Do we know who he is?
(
http://www.malfunction.org/erik/arkiv/anagrams.html)
While I'm at it, Mordred is half-brother to Gareth, heh, but that's really pushing it.
Beleg Cúthalion on 3/5/2009 at 09:32
Quote Posted by jtr7
I know "Modred" is a fairly common spelling for "Mordred", but I can't believe it's never been pointed out that it's an anagram of "dromed". :p
I thought it was too obvious and still far-fetched, however, I'm not so deep into the Arthurian myth anways.
jtr7 on 3/5/2009 at 10:31
Meaning, you don't think it was intentional? Me either.:)
So what's wrong with a happy triad of coincidences?
Dante on 3/5/2009 at 13:58
Quote Posted by Eigenface
As I see it, the thief factions are the worst possible sides of various groups in the real world.
I don't think so.
Quote:
For example, the Hammerites represent the Christian church at its most witch-burning, Crusading, and Spanish-Inquiring.
This is an obscene misrepresentation of the Catholic Church.
Quote:
This done so that Garrett the criminal seems like the good guy, rebelling against a world that's completely corrupt at every turn.
No. Garrett is the epitome of the
lovable rogue, a literary concept.
Quote:
Stealing? It's okay, because they're snobby nobles who make their wine from the blood and sweat of the common man.
I agree for the most part, but there are some instances where you can steal from innocent bourgeoisie.
Quote:
Killing? It's okay, because they're religious fanatics spreading blind obedience through brainwashing and torture.
Bullshit. Killing is rarely promoted in these games and when you do kill it's fairly personal. The Hammerites aren't simply religious fanatics. They do stand for some very noble values.
Quote:
This creates a pretty pessimistic viewpoint
Cynical.
Quote:
but on the other hand, Garrett wouldn't be a very sympathetic protagonist if he stole candy from babies and murdered their mothers.
Obviously. That could be said of the player character in any game.
Quote:
The only part that really bothers me about the thief world is how they conflate different things, that is, they poison good things by mixing them together with bad things. For example, because the slave-making Mechanists are the ones pushing for technological progress
The Hammerites are technologically progressive. The Mechanists are the embodiment of technological progressivism in excess.
Quote:
technological progress itself starts to look bad.
So you want to live in a sooty urban world where smog fills the sky and avaricious corporations cut down every tree in sight?
Quote:
Nature conservation takes the form of the pagans slaughtering the Hammerites en masse.
Did they? I don't remember this. :erg:
Quote:
Garrett is keeper of the balance.
He's the reluctant tool of the Keepers, yes.
Quote:
Things exist on one side or the other of a scale, and life is better when the scale is in balance, not when the good side is heavier - there is no real good side. This creates a
really pessimistic viewpoint.
Realistic, more like, although I would argue that there is a real good side in many matters.